Review: Limited Collectors’ Edition #C-34

Limited Collectors' Edition #C-34 cover
Cover by Nick Cardy

Limited Collectors’ Edition #C-34
Published and © by DC, February-March 1975

Title: “Silent Night, Deadly Night!”
Synopsis: Batman tracks down a perp who has been mugging Santa Clauses, then needs a Christmas miracle to make things right. 

Writer: Denny O’Neil
Penciler: Irv Novick
Inker: Dick Giordano

Review: These tabloid Christmas editions were always a seasonal treat. This lead story, from Batman #239, is good fun, provided the reader can be gracious with suspension of disbelief for the holidays. Irv Novick’s journeyman art is elevated by Dick Giordano’s excellent inking. This collection is off to a good start.


Title: “Billy Batson’s Xmas”
Synopsis: Captain Marvel helps out at the local department store, then exchanges gifts with the Marvel family – and himself.

Writer: Uncredited
Artist: Uncredited

Review: This reprint from Captain Marvel Adventures #69 is a clear reminder of comics’ tonal shift since the Golden Age. 


Title: “The $500,000 Doll Caper!”
Synopsis: Angel and Sam get pulled into Mr. Stooge’s villainous plot, but get some help from Santa.

Writer: John Albano
Penciler: Bob Oksner
Inker: Wally Wood

Review: This new Angel and the Ape story is madcap insanity. It makes little sense but features some nice cartooning.


Title: “A Swingin’ Christmas Carol”
Synopsis: Mr. Scrounge is mixed up in some shady business, but has a Christmas change of heart thanks to the Titans. 

Writer: Bob Haney
Artist: Nick Cardy

Review: A “Christmas Carol” riff  from Teen Titans #13 featuring villains guilty of … recycling? A silly story but  masterful cartooning.


Title: “Christmastown, U.S.A.”
Synopsis: Lois and Clark are assigned to write a feature on Christmastown, but a flood and amnesia threaten the seasonal fun.

Writer: Uncredited
Penciler: Uncredited

Review: This ridiculous reprint from Action Comics #117 sees Superman more interested in Christmas trappings than helping stop a flood.

Grade (for the entire issue): B

Second opinion: “This is what a holiday-themed special should be. … 4 out of 4 stars.” – Brett Frankenhoff, Comics Buyer’s Guide #1673, January 2011

Cool factor: Who wouldn’t want this tabloid special sticking out of their stocking?

Notable: This issue also includes a 1975 super-hero calendar, Christmas quizes, activity pages and other filler features.

Character quotable: “If you find the creep, sock ’im one for old Santa!” – a charity bell ringer, demonstrating the ol’ Christmas spirit

Editor’s note: This review was written Dec. 12, 2021.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.